GUILTY or NOT?

GUILTY or NOT? / Case library

The Cocoanut Grove

Commonwealth v. Welansky (1943)

Charge: Involuntary Manslaughter — 19 Counts Heard on GUILTY or NOT?: 30 June 2026

The facts

On November 28, 1942, fire broke out in the basement Melody Lounge of the Cocoanut Grove nightclub in Boston, operated and wholly controlled by the Defendant. A 16-year-old bar boy lit a match to see a lightbulb in a dark corner, inadvertently igniting an artificial palm tree. The fire spread across the low cloth ceiling almost instantly. Approximately 1,000 patrons were in the club — nearly double its capacity. Multiple emergency exits were locked, blocked with furniture, or hidden behind decorative drapes. The main entrance had a single revolving door that jammed immediately with panicking people. A rear exit was kept locked to prevent customers from leaving without paying. In the ensuing crush, 492 people died — the deadliest nightclub fire in American history. The Defendant was hospitalized when the fire occurred, but had personally run every aspect of the club for nine years.

You have the facts the court had. Did the prosecution prove it? Render your verdict in the game, then see what the court actually decided — and why.

Citation: 316 Mass. 383, 55 N.E.2d 902 (Mass. 1944)

Read the full decision at law.justia.com. The source reveals the outcome.

← All cases