GUILTY or NOT?

GUILTY or NOT? / Case library

The Last Call

People v. Watson (1983)

Charge: Murder — Second Degree (2 Counts) Heard on GUILTY or NOT?: 14 August 2026

The facts

In the early morning hours of January 3, 1979, the Defendant left a Redding, California bar after consuming large quantities of beer. Approximately ninety minutes later, the Defendant drove through a red light on a city street, narrowly avoiding a collision only by skidding to a halt in the middle of the intersection. Rather than stopping, he accelerated to high speed and entered a second intersection, where he struck a Toyota sedan. Three passengers were ejected from the vehicle. The driver and her six-year-old daughter were killed. The Defendant left 112 feet of skid marks before impact and 180 feet after. The posted speed limit was 35 mph; expert analysis placed his speed at 70–84 mph at the moment of impact. A breathalyzer administered thirty minutes after the crash recorded a blood alcohol content of 0.23% — more than twice the legal limit. The Prosecution charged the Defendant with two counts of second-degree murder, arguing his conduct amounted to implied malice.

You have the facts the court had. Did the prosecution prove it? Render your verdict in the game, then see what the court actually decided — and why.

Citation: 30 Cal.3d 290, 179 Cal.Rptr. 43, 637 P.2d 279 (Cal. 1981)

Read the full decision at law.justia.com. The source reveals the outcome.

← All cases